Choosing a University

Choosing a university is not an easy decision. For some students, the choice will be made for them, they can only really afford to live at home and go to the closest university. For other students, they can potentially study at any university in Australia or New Zealand.

Factors to consider when choosing a university

There are many factors to consider when choosing a university. What’s important to one student is not necessarily important to another. Probably the biggest myth is that university ranking is the most important thing to consider. This is discussed indepth later in this chapter, but for now we focus on other factors to keep in mind.

Accommodation costs

Accommodation costs either on-campus in university housing or a nearby location can be eye-wateringly expensive. It’s not uncommon for students to move into accommodation and then realise that they are struggling to afford it. Make sure to budget carefully before moving in. Once you’ve signed a contract, it could be difficult to move out without financial penalties. Unsurprisingly, despite a desire for independence, many students live with their parent(s) during their time as an undergraduate due to financial constraints.

Accreditation

Does the university offer the degree that you are interested in and is it properly accredited? Sometimes universities will offer a degree that sounds like it leads to a particular profession, but really it doesn’t (at least not directly).

For instance, the University of Auckland offers a degree in Medical Physics and Imaging Technology which sounds like it qualifies you to work as a medical imaging technologist or medical physicist, but does it? No it doesn’t! To work as a medical physicist in New Zealand, the only approved qualification is a Master of Science (MSc) in Medical Physics from the University of Canterbury. The undergraduate degree from Auckland might help with later accredited studies, but a general physics or even an engineering degree is adequate for entry to the MSc course.

Similarly, only certain qualifications that are approved by the New Zealand Medical Radiation Technologists Board will allow someone to practice as medical imaging technologist. The BSc in Medical Physics and Imaging Technology is not on the list.

The University of Auckland does actually offer a different approved qualification, the Bachelor of Medical Imaging (Honours). As we have shown, it is very easy for students that don’t research choices carefully to get confused about what different degrees offer in terms of course content and job opportunities.

There may be some scenarios where accreditation doesn’t really matter, such as when it comes to information technology degrees. Information technology isn’t a regulated profession. In the Australian job market, nobody really cares about accreditation from the Australian Computer Society (ACS). Less than 5% of Australian IT professionals are members [1]. If you want to use the degree for migration purposes though, ACS accreditation may be needed as they have managed to insert themselves in this process.

Tip
Sometimes accreditation is critical, and you will not be able to get a job in that area without it. Other times it isn’t needed. Be sure to investigate carefully.

A surprisingly common misconception is students studying a degree in pharmacology and thinking they can then work as a pharmacist, but that is not the case. It’s critically important to understand what your degree qualifies you to do and whether it is properly accredited. Universities have been known to market courses in a misleading way or say they have accreditation when they don’t.

Tip
Universities can market degrees in misleading ways. Carefully research what a particular degree qualifies you for.

Programme availability

Ensure the university offers your desired programme. Especially in a small country like New Zealand and even in Australia, some more specialised programmes like dentistry are only offered at a few universities. Sometimes students naively assume that their chosen major is offered at every university.

Location

The general environment can have a big impact on how an individual feels about their university. Some students might prefer a big city, others a more regional location. Given the sky-high rents in major cities a regional location could offer lower costs. Even within a city there is a lot of variation with some universities located close to the central business district (CBD) while others are in a quiet outer suburb. While some might want more hustle and bustle, keep in mind that you are at university to study, too many distractions might impact your grades.

In addition, consider the quality of public transportation. A shorter stress-free commute will do a lot to improve your university experience. Try to spend time exploring a given university before making a final decision. Different locations can facilitate different lifestyles, some students who love surfing may choose a university with easy access to surf beaches. Easy access to recreational opportunities can do a lot to improve the overall experience.

Tip
Location can have a big impact on the overall experience as well as costs.

Fees and expenses

Fees for domestic students are set by the government at public universities, but for international students, there is no limit to what universities can charge. Sometimes students might obsess over studying at a high ranked university and be faced with huge fees. Yet this additional spending may not pay off in the long run. A degree from a cheaper university might be just as good.

In the opposite extreme, international students might just take the cheapest option which may also not make economic sense in that the degree is poor quality. In New Zealand, some students may skip university all together and choose a polytechnic degree. Unfortunately, these degrees are sometimes not respected. Hence, it is important to research carefully. In addition, pay attention to your budget because although Australian and New Zealand students studying in their respective countries have access to student loans, these might not be enough to cover all expenses.

Tip
For international students, it doesn’t always make sense to select the most prestigious university which is likely very expensive, nor does it make sense to just choose the cheapest option. A careful balancing act is required.

Statistics

It’s a good idea to examine any statistics that are available around student satisfaction, employment rates and so on, but keep in mind these can be impacted by significant non-response rates.

Support

What kind of support does the university offer? Some students may have disabilities that need special support or mental health issues that require ongoing counselling. Be advised that at nearly all universities the demand for support like counselling far exceeds available resources. You might be hoping to receive ongoing counselling, but in reality be limited to a couple of sessions.

Facilities

Take a look at what facilities are available. Even the busiest student will want to spend time relaxing and exercising. What sporting facilities are available? How busy are they? Inner city universities especially are quite cramped and don’t have enough facilities for all students. Moreover, as some universities have cranked up international enrolments, overcrowding has become an issue. There isn’t even enough study space. The library and other areas suitable for study are crowded and it can be impossible to find a seat. Similarly, the pool, gym and other recreational facilities are also packed.

Food options

It might seem trivial, but being able to get quality food at a decent price on campus can make a big difference to your mood and overall experience. Is there a single provider of unappetising and overpriced slop? Or is there a diverse range of good quality choices at reasonable prices? Campuses are generally open to the public, so evaluating food options could be part of a general fact-finding visit to a university.

Students are often curious whether universities will help them find internships. This is rarely the case, although some degrees do incorporate periods of industry experience or industry based learning which count towards the degree. Though due to their popularity, there are often way more applicants than places. In addition, the number of places available can fluctuate dependent on economic conditions. Universities have been known to pull a bait and switch and suddenly change the rules. So students think they are going to get industry based learning but then don’t because the required grades suddenly get increased. If industry links are important to you, check out what is available.

Tip
Most universities won’t help you find an internship. Nor will they provide job placement after graduation.

Research opportunities

Research opportunities aren’t important to everyone, but those intending on pursuing a PhD and a research career will want exposure to research as early as possible. In this case consider the university’s research output in your subject of interest. Some universities are more research oriented than others and also may focus on certain areas.

Entry requirements

Ensure you meet the entry requirements for the programme. If you aren’t accepted into the programme but are accepted into an equivalent degree elsewhere, it is almost always better to take that alternative offer. Some students may focus on a particular university and start in a degree they aren’t really interested in hoping to transfer later, but this can waste a lot of time and may not be successful.

Quality

The quality of the programme is obviously of critical importance. Don’t think quality and ranking are the same. Highly ranked universities can offer degrees that are regarded as poor quality.

New Zealand universities

New Zealand only has 8 universities.

  • Auckland University of Technology (AUT)

  • Lincoln University

  • Massey University

  • University of Auckland

  • University of Canterbury

  • University of Otago

  • University of Waikato

  • Victoria University of Wellington

There are some perceived differences in the prestige of the universities, however, there is little evidence that employers prefer the graduates of one New Zealand university to another. Certainly, the choice of degree / major will have a far larger impact on lifetime earnings than the choice of university. Also, the small number of universities means that some degrees are only offered at one or two universities. For example, medicine is only available at the University of Auckland and University of Otago (with a planned medical school at the University of Waikato), and the only dental school is at Otago.

Whereas universities in countries like the US have huge differences in their financial resources, all universities in New Zealand are funded by the central government. What is more, they are all subject to a reasonable amount of regulation and oversight, meaning there isn’t as much scope for variation between universities. Additionally, although there are a few degrees that are highly selective (like medicine) in general, no university is highly selective when it comes to a typical undergraduate degree in science, commerce or arts. Students can mistakenly think that the University of Auckland, because it has the highest ranking, is like the Oxford or Harvard of New Zealand when that is absolutely not the case.

Any differences in research output are likely to have little impact on most undergraduate students. In fact, it is just as likely that a high research output could negatively impact undergraduate quality of education since staff are preoccupied with research rather than teaching.

Australian universities

There are four main groupings of Australian Universities. The most well known is the Group of Eight. Universities which aren’t in any of the groupings are sometimes referred to as unaligned.

Group of Eight

The group of Eight consists of the oldest, largest and most prestigious universities in Australia.

  • Australian National University

  • Monash University

  • University of Adelaide

  • University of Melbourne

  • University of New South Wales

  • University of Queensland

  • University of Sydney

  • University of Western Australia

Australian Technology Network (ATN)

These evolved from existing Institutes of Technology in the 1980s:

  • Curtin University

  • University of Technology Sydney (UTS)

  • RMIT University (RMIT)

  • Queensland University of Technology (QUT)

  • University of South Australia (UniSA)

Regional

The Regional Universities Network (RUN) consists of those newer universities whose main campus is in a regional area. They include:

  • Southern Cross University (SCU)

  • University of New England (UNE)

  • Federation University Australia (FedUni)

  • University of the Sunshine Coast (USC)

  • Central Queensland University (CQUniversity)

  • University of Southern Queensland (USQ)

Innovative Research Universities (IRU)

Innovative Research Universities (IRU): These universities were established in the 1960s and 1970s:

  • Murdoch University

  • Flinders University

  • Griffith University

  • James Cook University (JCU)

  • Newcastle University

  • La Trobe University

  • Charles Darwin University (CDU);

  • Victoria University (VU)

University prestige / ranking. How much does it matter?

I got offered a place in several other universities, but I really want to study at Monash. It’s a group of eight university and one of the top ranked nursing degrees in Australia. Unfortunately I didn’t get accepted. Should I apply again next year? This is so depressing. I don’t know what I should do?
— Alina discussing her plans to study nursing

University ranking is probably the one factor that students tend to overestimate the importance of. This can lead to a variety of outcomes such as delaying the start of their degree, enrolling in a programme that doesn’t really interest them (in the hopes of getting high enough grades that they can then apply next year for their desired programme), or undertaking a huge commute! It’s not uncommon to hear of students undertaking a four-hour round trip across Melbourne in order to go to a higher ranked university despite there being a decent university much closer. Prestige may matter in some scenarios, but for many occupations prestige matters little.

When it comes to nursing, for example, payscales are largely set by the government, and it doesn’t matter where you studied. Australian hospitals and medical centres are full of nurses from nursing schools all around Australia and the globe. Indeed, for most health care professions like nursing, pharmacy, dentistry, physiotherapy and so on, the prestige / ranking of the university doesn’t matter. Rankings are calculated based on a number of variables, most of which are irrelevant to the quality of training you will receive. Later in your career, if you wish to move to more senior roles, where you studied is unlikely to play a major factor.

Even if we assume that studying at a prestigious university gives a small boost, what matters in the long run is the individual’s skills, experience, and personality. Employers are going to value practical experience and personality while where you studied originally fades into obscurity.

University ranking is featured heavily in university marketing materials, implying a level of importance in career outcomes that isn’t justified.

Tip
University prestige and ranking isn’t as important for most students as is portrayed. Don’t weight it too heavily when choosing a university.

Don’t be fooled and think that universities are highly selective elite institutions. Some students think that the higher ranked universities in Australia are the equivalent of Oxford or Harvard, and that by studying there you too will become part of an exclusive group. That isn’t the case, in general even the highest ranked universities aren’t all that selective.

Group of Eight (Go8) www.go8.edu.au

The Group of Eight(Go8) are consistently the highest ranked universities in Australia. It’s commonly thought that Go8 universities deliver a better quality of education and hence their graduates are more productive in the workforce. This increase in productivity could mean that employers are willing to offer higher salaries to Go8 graduates.

But does graduating from a Go8 university really deliver a higher income? A 2009 study by Birch and associates found little difference in starting salaries between Go8 graduates and those of other universities [2]. A more recent study by Koshy and associates used data from the Household, Income and Labour Dynamics in Australia (HILDA) Survey to investigate this question. They also found little evidence of a significant difference between Go8 and other groups of universities [3]. The only exception was that those graduates from universities in the Regional Universities Network (RUN) earned about 11% less than other graduates. The study suggested that the lower incomes associated with regional universities were possibly not due to the universities themselves, but rather the fact that many graduates worked in regional labour markets which have lower associated rates of pay. They emphasised that the field of study was much more important than institution when it comes to earnings.

Tip
Field of study is much more important than university in determining earnings

In contrast, a 2019 article found that while a Go8 premia does exist, it is a relatively minor driver of graduate salaries. The authors calculated the size of the premia to be about 5%, yet a sizeable portion of this premia (between 13 and 46%) is due to recruiting smarter students with higher ATARs. It is likely these smarter students may outperform others when it comes to earnings regardless of where they study [4]. Specifically, once the investigators control for factors like ATAR, field of study, and which region the graduate works, the premia decreases in size. Comparing a Go8 university to an ATN university, for example, only shows a premia of around 2%. It’s not uncommon for students to go to great lengths and inconvenience to study at say Monash or the University of Melbourne rather than study at RMIT, but these results suggest this effort doesn’t really pay off.

University rankings are generated from many variables such as the number of research articles published, which are unlikely to contribute much to the quality of education a student receives, especially if they have no plans to pursue a research career. Similarly, a university having better staff to student ratios doesn’t necessarily help students if those staff are preoccupied with research rather than focused on teaching.

It seems probable based on existing research that many students are unduly concerned about going to the highest ranked university - they are better to consider a broad range of factors when choosing a university.

Note
A lot of factors contribute to university ranking, but many of them aren’t directly relevant to the quality of education a student receives

It may be the case that for students pursuing post graduate studies like a PhD that a Go8 university confers a benefit by being more focused on research, but even then it may not be the best choice if an alternative university has a research group that specialises in the topic of interest. It’s important to look at all factors in detail rather than make assumptions based solely on a university’s rank.

Polytechnic degrees

The focus of this book is on university and university degrees, but we briefly mention degrees offered by Polytechnics and TAFEs.

New Zealand polytechnics offer a range of degrees. It is important to note that these are not universities. Some students get confused and think they are studying at a university when they are not. In the situation where a student plans to undertake more advanced post-graduate education, only having a polytechnic degree could be limiting. Some universities overseas may not recognise it or not respect it.

On the other hand, for those looking for a purely vocational education and who plan to gain a qualification and enter the job market, a polytechnic degree could be a valid choice for certain professions. For some vocations, employers won’t care whether the degree is from a university or polytechnic.

New Zealand polytechnics have a long history of delivering nursing education. For those wanting to be a nurse, a polytech degree is worth considering. Especially for those who want a practically focused education. Another good choice is the fully accredited medical imaging degree offered by the confusingly named Unitec.

Polytechnics also offer a range of engineering technology degrees. These may be useful for some students depending on the kind of job they are seeking. Be aware though that they are only 3 years in duration and are not accredited under the Washington Accord, which makes it very difficult to become a Chartered Professional Engineer. In other words, they only qualify the graduate as an engineering technician.

If you can’t get into the university degree that you want, and an equivalent polytechnic qualification is available, it can make sense to pursue the polytechnic qualification. Any extra value from the university qualification will be eroded by the time wasted trying to gain entry.

For some occupations, a polytechnic degree has the same value in the job market as a university degree. But for other occupations it could be less valued and not respected.

Tip
Polytechnic degrees are worth considering. In some professions, having a non-university degree will be satisfactory.

TAFE degrees

In Australia, Technical and Further Education (TAFE) colleges offer a range of vocational courses. Traditionally, these have been at below degree level and comprised of a range of certifications and diplomas. More recently, some TAFE colleges have offered bachelor’s and even master’s degrees.

Are these degrees worth considering? The answer is similar to that for New Zealand. For some areas like nursing or early childhood education, having a TAFE degree will be regarded as meeting the educational requirements for the profession. Maybe a few snobs will look down at them, but in the majority of cases it won’t matter.

If your ATAR is terrible, and you can’t get into the university degree you want, it is worthwhile at least considering a TAFE qualification and looking at the different pathways available.

Suppose you live in New South Wales and want to study accounting, but have been rejected by all universities. It is worth looking at offerings such as the Bachelor of Applied Commerce at TAFE NSW. Being realistic though, the so-called Big Four accounting firms will likely not recruit a TAFE graduate when they have plenty of university graduates applying. This will mean kicking off your accounting career at small firms and working your way up.

Tip
TAFE degrees are worth considering in some scenarios. For some occupations they will be adequate, but in other cases they won’t be respected. Especially if there is a surplus of graduates in those fields.

Even the top universities in Australia or New Zealand aren’t Ivy Leagues.

Since the myth is so common, it is worth repeating that the top ranked universities in Australia and New Zealand aren’t hugely selective when it comes to most degrees. Don’t mistakenly think you will be attending the equivalent of an Ivy League. Some students think they have to submit an admission essay, personal statement, or letters of recommendation, in order to be accepted. In the vast majority of degrees no such documents are required. Unless the degree specifically asks for those things you are just wasting your time submitting the documents.

Conclusion

There are so many factors to consider when choosing a university and each student will weight them differently. In order to adequately weigh up the different options, ideally make a number of visits to the various campuses as well as spend time investigating online. Too many students want to outsource their research by asking on social media "Which university is better A or B ?"' Answering that question is complex, and nobody can really answer it in a social media comment.

Future students often put far too much emphasis on university ranking or prestige. The evidence suggests that this has minimal influence on salaries or career. Certainly, it isn’t worthwhile delaying the start of a degree in the hopes of eventually receiving an offer from a high ranked university.

Bibliography

[2] E. R. Birch, I. Li, and P. W. Miller, “The influences of institution attended and field of study on graduates’ starting salaries,” Australian Economic Review, vol. 42, no. 1, pp. 42–63, 2009.

[3] P. Koshy, R. Seymour, and M. Dockery, “Are there institutional differences in the earnings of Australian higher education graduates?,” Economic Analysis and Policy, vol. 51, pp. 1–11, 2016.

[4] D. Carroll, C. Heaton, and M. Tani, “Does It Pay to Graduate from an ’Elite’ University in Australia?,” Economic Record, vol. 95, no. 310, pp. 343–357, 2019.