Exposure
A characteristic of social anxiety is avoiding situations that makes a person anxious. Yet avoiding the situation means never becoming accustomed to it, and never realising that it is unlikely to have the feared negative outcome. In short, avoidance means that the fear continues.
A key technique for dealing with social anxiety is exposure. This means facing the anxiety provoking situation in a controlled and graduated manner. Over time, we become more accustomed to the situation and anxiety levels lower. It is important that the exposure occurs relatively often. Another benefit is improving social skills, for which frequent practice is also important.
-
Controlled
-
Predictable
-
Graduated
-
Frequent
-
Designed to challenge feared outcomes
-
Occurs in a variety of different places and situations
-
Makes use of cognitive strategies to challenge unhelpful thoughts
Escaping a social situation that is causing anxiety may indeed bring a feeling of relief, but this feeling of relief can reward the avoidance behaviour. Sometimes students even resort to using alcohol to lower their anxiety. This can lead to undesirable consequences such as dependency. By approaching a situation without alcohol, anxiety can decrease naturally.
When planning exposure, it is important to plan carefully starting with less feared situations and building up to more difficult ones. Exposure practice might be challenging at times, but shouldn’t feel impossible. Improperly thought-out exposure not only is unlikely to help, but could make things worse. Exposure also links back to the distorted automatic thoughts in the previous section. It allows us to identify the automatic thoughts that occur in certain situations and to test how real they are. Identifying the automatic thoughts allows us to challenge them and create rational responses.
|
Tip
|
Carefully graduated exposure to feared situations is an important technique for overcoming anxiety. It can reveal that feared situations aren’t as bad as perceived. It also helps identify dysfunctional automatic thoughts which can then be addressed using cognitive techniques. |
Situational exposure involves exposing ourselves to the situations that produce anxiety. But as part of building up to situational exposure, we can also use imagined exposure. This is where we imagine ourselves in the scenario and mentally practice navigating the situation and considering how we would handle various possibilities.
Sometimes students will claim they are too busy to do the exposure practice. While it’s true that some students are very busy, their future path in life depends on making progress in addressing social anxiety. Completing the exposure practice needs to be a priority.
How to plan and conduct exposure practice
If you tell yourself that you want to overcome social anxiety but don’t take concrete action, then the problem is going to persist. Many students are busy with assignments and other tasks, but in order to make improvements, they have to find a way to incorporate exposure practice into their schedule. Think of it as like exercising. Nobody gets in shape if they keep putting off exercising. Similar to exercising, exposure practice should ideally take place several times a week.
|
Tip
|
Having a happy and productive life often depends on overcoming social anxiety. For this reason, regular exposure practice needs to be a priority in order to make progress. |
-
Make a plan of what you want to practice and set aside blocks of time.
-
Start with easier situations and build up to more challenging ones. Avoid overwhelming yourself.
-
Select situations where things are predictable and you have some degree of control.
-
Use the cognitive techniques discussed previously to manage self-defeating anxiety-provoking thoughts.
-
Consider possible outcomes that could occur during practice and prepare a response.
After the initial surge of anxiety, the longer you stay in an exposure situation, the lower your anxiety will become. You will also start to realise that many of the feared outcomes don’t eventuate. For this reason, longer exposures are typically better than shorter ones. Suppose you are afraid of going to a party. Instead of leaving after a short time, instead stay longer so your anxiety subsides, and you have a chance to start feeling more comfortable.
Exposure is more effective if the practices are close together. For example, if you fear asking a question in class, don’t just ask a question once per month. Try to ask a question every week. Obviously, if your feared situation is parties, and you are starting from a point of a limited number of friends, then you might not get invited to a party every week or even every month. In this case, you need to try and find situations that are similar to the social conditions at a party such as those that involve making small talk. This could be done by joining university clubs and societies or other groups in the community that meet on a regular basis and offer the opportunity for casual conversation.
|
Tip
|
If the feared situation is not available, or not available frequently, look for other opportunities to practice similar skills. |
For students, it may be possible to incorporate exposure practice into their daily routine. Although universities often have environments that make it hard to find friends, there are still many opportunities for superficial social interactions. These could take place in halls of residence, the university gym, the classroom, or other locations. Every person has some unique aspects to their social anxiety. But as a general principle, the more combinations of situations and people you can use for practice, the more progress can be made.
Set goals for exposure practice that are realistic, measurable and under your control. It might be tempting to set a goal like "complete presentation without feeling anxious". While anxiety levels will tend to decrease over time, it is not realistic to eliminate them as a short-term goal. Even confident extroverts still can feel a bit anxious when giving a presentation. Instead, focus on trying to accomplish what you want to achieve in a situation such as "complete presentation while keeping anxiety under control".
|
Tip
|
Set goals to demonstrate progress. Choose goals that can be objectively evaluated. |
Role-Plays and imaginary exposure
Situational Role-playing is a useful technique. This means using a friend or family member to practice being in a particular situation. For instance, if you have to give a speech in class, practice giving it in front of your friend. Your friend can give you feedback on the speech or any behaviours that might be distracting from your message. The friend can also ask questions similar to those that an audience member might ask.
While perhaps not as effective as some other exposure techniques, it is sometimes useful to use imagined exposure. As you might anticipate, this involves imagining some aspects of the situation. In the case of making a public speech, you could imagine yourself standing in front of an audience while reading your speech out loud. You might think about what your emotions and thoughts are and how you will respond to them. What is the audience doing? What sounds are coming from the audience such as people coughing, rustling papers and so on. Imagine yourself successfully giving a speech. You can even imagine some minor issues such as someone asking a question you don’t know the answer too. In that situation it is fine to answer something like, "I’m not 100% sure, but I’ll get back to you on that".
Be realistic
Be realistic about what will happen during exposure practices. You are going to feel a bit uncomfortable and things won’t always go according to plan. However, you can learn from what happens and use that to create improved plans for future exposure practices and to build additional strategies for dealing with various scenarios. Use the cognitive techniques to cope with any unhelpful thoughts that occur.
Remember that although anxiety will make you feel a bit uncomfortable, it will subside over time and isn’t dangerous. On rare occasions something you feared might actually happen. Someone might criticise you, or respond in an unfriendly manner. Someone might laugh at a mistake you’ve made or make a sarcastic remark. It’s part of life that this type of thing will sometimes happen. Everybody else will quickly forget about it, they are busy worrying about their own problems.
Rumination is the repetitive thinking or dwelling on negative feelings and experiences. It’s common for those with social anxiety to ruminate on social situations that they perceive didn’t go well, but this can create a neverending cycle of negative thoughts and heighten anxiety in the future.
|
Tip
|
On rare occasions something bad might happen. This will be quickly forgotten by the other people present and most likely be insignificant in the longer term. Try not to ruminate on these situations as it just makes your anxiety worse. |
Cognitive restructuring
As mentioned, cognitive strategies are an integrated part of exposure. This means using the cognitive restructuring techniques prior to each exposure to help develop rational responses to any maladaptive automatic thoughts that occur.
-
Imagine yourself in the situation. Write down the automatic thoughts that are occurring.
-
Identify the thinking errors.
-
Pick two or three thoughts that seem most significant and develop rational responses.
After the exposure
After the exposure practice, it’s helpful to review what happened and whether you achieved your goal. What automatic thoughts occurred, were there any you hadn’t noticed before? Do you need to apply cognitive restructuring to them? Was there anything that didn’t quite go to plan that you can work on for next time? Did your fears about the situation occur, or was it not as bad as you anticipated?
Be careful of thinking errors like disqualifying the positive. You might focus on negative aspects rather than your positive achievements. Sometimes you might be feeling discouraged, embarrassed, or experiencing other negative thoughts. For those with social anxiety, focusing on a few negative aspects of the situation is quite common, but unhelpful. This is because it discourages you from trying future similar social interactions.
Now it is time to start thinking about the next exposure. Remember, it is better to make slow and steady progress rather than tackle something too challenging and be overwhelmed by anxiety.
The university environment
The university environment provides a lot of opportunities for situational exposure. This can range from making small talk to public speaking. Many students skip any tutorial, workshop or other class that isn’t compulsory. Instead of doing this, go to all of them and take advantage of the situational exposure opportunities that arise.
In addition, there are often clubs and societies that can be joined. You might even build up to getting involved in the committee or other organisational activities for a club. If the university doesn’t offer clubs that look appealing, search for other ones in the community. Another opportunity is voluntary workshops and seminars offered by the university on topics such as academic skills. Although some universities have moved these kind of support services solely online, others continue to offer them in a mix of in person and online formats.
Don’t be afraid to join a club or activity you don’t even really care about. If you make some mistakes, it won’t matter since there’s nobody you are trying to impress. By getting exposure in less threatening situations, you can practice behavioural skills. This leaves you prepared for later higher stakes situations.
|
Tip
|
University offers many opportunities for situational exposure. Take advantage of all the opportunities on offer. Most situations are low stakes, so if you make a mistake, it won’t matter. |
Public speaking
A common fear is speaking in public. This fear can involve a range of activities from asking a question in a tutorial to making a presentation in front of a large group. Basically any situation that involves having to articulate your thoughts in front of a group and being the centre of attention can be considered public speaking.
Fortunately, the university environment offers numerous ways to practice public speaking and implement an exposure practice plan. This could involve starting by asking questions in class and then building up to taking an organisational role in a club where you need to speak in front of a group. Since some group projects may involve presenting in front of a class, you could volunteer to take on the role of lead presenter if you feel it is something you can handle. Though if you are still at an early stage of your journey of coping with social anxiety don’t overwhelm yourself.
Making small talk and socialising
This is another skill that many students want to develop but feel anxious about. Just like with public speaking, university offers an abundance of opportunities for small talk. Go to every tutorial or workshop even if it is voluntary. Greet the people in your vicinity as they turn up. Ask the people sitting nearby about their experience with the course, upcoming assignments, impressions of a test etc. Obviously not everyone is chatty and expect some will not want to talk. They might even have social anxiety themselves. But you will probably find some classmates who are happy to talk and especially share any issues they are having at university.
Take every opportunity to make small talk with your peers. Even just greeting people and not saying anything else is an important first step. As mentioned previously, join up with various clubs and societies and use them to practice small talk.
The obvious challenge for many students, especially those doing demanding degrees, is to find enough time to for situational exposure on top of other commitments. This means it is critical to find ways to combine situational exposure with university work. One option is meeting for lunch to discuss an assignment or organising a study group where you can work together on exam preparation or assignments (without violating academic integrity rules). If you propose such a meeting to your classmates, and they look uncomfortable or make an excuse, don’t take it personally. Just move on. There are numerous reasons why someone might not want to meet, many of which have nothing to do with you.
If you are living in university halls of residence, strike up conversations with other people you see. Ask them about what they are studying, where they are from, what their interests are, and so on.
Job interviews
Many students want to find a part-time job but are terrified when it comes to interviews. Get your friend or family member to help you practice by taking on the role of interviewer. They can point out areas for improvement. As you get better at interviews, they can take on the role of a tough and more hostile interviewer. It’s a good idea to research what type of questions are commonly asked in interviews. These days, behavioural interviews seem popular, but be prepared for a broad range of questions.
If the actual interview was unsuccessful, tell yourself it was just practice for the next one. Also console yourself that there are really no dream part-time jobs and there is a reasonable chance the job was terrible anyway. Applying for jobs and going to interviews is often a numbers game. All other things being equal, the more jobs you apply for, the more interviews you will get, and the more interviews you get, the more offers you will receive.
Sample exposure plan for a student that is uncomfortable making small talk
Every person is facing their own unique challenges. But here is a plan for a student who is uncomfortable making small talk and how they can plan situational exposure over a semester.
Weeks 1-3
Goals for the first few weeks are just to grow more accustomed to being around other students and to overcome fear of initial interactions
-
Say "hi" to other students in your tutorials, workshops or who live in your halls of residence.
-
Ask another student for directions to a location on campus.
-
Sit in some crowded area and get used to lots of other students being around.
If you greet other students, they might want to start a conversation. It’s a good idea to be prepared to talk about yourself such as what other classes you are taking, hobbies, interests, where you are from, etc.
Weeks 4-6
After getting used to greeting other students, you want to move to the next phase which is to improve your ability to make small talk. Hopefully by now you know some classmates by sight, so you won’t just be some stranger starting small talk. Also use common sense and don’t interrupt someone if they appear to be busy. Remember as well that when making small talk, you don’t need to talk all that much. Often other students will have bottled up complaints or worries that they can’t wait to share. This means you can focus on listening. Another idea is to look for common ground, for example, they might have stickers on their laptop or be wearing clothing that suggests a particular interest. If they don’t seem that willing to communicate, then don’t feel discouraged, try again later with a different student.
-
What classes are you taking this semester?
-
Did you already start work on the essay / assignment? What do you think?
-
Are you a member of any university clubs or societies?
-
Do you have any hobbies?
-
What is your major? Why did you choose that?
-
What kind of job do you want after graduation?
-
Are you originally from city XYZ or did you move here for university? (for a university located in city XYZ)
-
How are you finding university so far?
-
How did you find the last assignment?
-
Do you listen to music while studying?
-
What’s your favourite type of music to listen to while studying?
-
How’s your semester going so far?
-
What do you think of the university’s campus?
The conversation can then be extended by using phrases like "that sounds interesting - how long have you been into that?", "really, why did you choose that?", or "do you have any hints?" as appropriate.
Weeks 9 - 12
As the semester progresses, now is the time to take on more novel situations. This can mean going to events on campus and introducing yourself to strangers. Or asking a classmate to meet you outside of class to discuss an assignment or preparation for exams.
Sample plan for a student that is uncomfortable with public speaking
Some universities may have clubs dedicated to public speaking or some activity that involves public speaking like debating. They are worth considering depending on your level of anxiety. For those with higher levels of anxiety, it might be preferable to leave those to later semesters depending on how quickly you can make progress.
Weeks 1-3
-
Practice "public speaking" in your room.
Weeks 4-6
-
Ask a question in a tutorial or workshop.
-
Ask a question or make a comment in a university club or society.
-
Record yourself making a speech and then watch it and look for ways to make improvements.
Weeks 6-9
-
Give a short talk in front of a small group of friends or flatmates.
Weeks 9-12
In weeks 9-12 it is time to give a talk in front of a group you don’t necessarily know that well and who might be more critical. It’s often the case that group projects are starting to become due, and you may need to do a presentation at university as part of your course. Practice the presentation a few times at home so you are familiar with the material. Familiarise yourself with any guidelines the course has for class presentations.
-
If appropriate, give a short talk at a club or society you are a member of.
-
Give a presentation in class.
Later Weeks
At the end of the semester, you will probably be busy with exams, but after the semester is over look for opportunities to continue to practice and maintain progress. You could look for volunteer options on campus such as a tour guide for potential students.
Sample plan for Jasmine doing a fashion show
You may remember Jasmine from the previous chapter, she has been attending her university fashion club for a while. Next week they are having a "fashion show" where each person needs to create a new spring look and model their selection. The fashion club has been going well, but Jasmine is very nervous about presenting her look in front of everyone. Jasmine prepares for the fashion club by first practicing in front of a small group consisting of her flatmate and her friend Kayla from the fashion club. Jasmine doesn’t even need to explain to them all the details about this being an exposure situation, instead she can just ask them to help her prepare.
Jasmine sets a goal of going through each item she has selected for her spring look, saying something about each item individually, and then about the whole look she has chosen.
Summary
Exposure is a critical strategy for reducing social anxiety. A general principle is to tackle increasingly difficult situations over time. Before each situation use the process of cognitive restructuring and develop rational responses. Eventually, your progress on addressing anxiety will generalise to other situations. You will feel less anxious despite not having explicitly prepared for those situations. It might seem like the process is a lot of work, and it could be tempting to skip over some steps, but a slow and steady approach usually pays off in the long run.